The 10 Best Cake Shops in Wisconsin!

Who doesn’t like cake? From cool designs for themed parties and events to the best tasting batter—Wisconsin does it best. The best cake shops in Wisconsin put quality before anything else. Ditch the boxed cake mix and call up our favorite cake shops for you next celebration!

1. Carl’s Cakes, Sun Prairie, WI

If you’re in the Madison area and you need a tasty cake for you next event, you go to Carl’s Cakes located in Sun Prairie. They are an award-winning bakery located within The Market Street Diner. More than just wedding cakes, they do sheet cakes for birthdays, anniversaries and more. Try their raspberry-filled butter cream cake! 

2. Simma’s Bakery, Milwaukee, WI

Simma’s Bakery was voted one of America’s Top 25 Bakeries—so you know they’ve taken the cake (Get it?) in Milwaukee. This family-owned bake shop will knock your socks off with their tasty cakes. From cheese cakes to sheet cakes, all the way up to eccentric wedding cakes—Simma’s got you covered!

3. Aggie’s Bakery and Cake Shop, West Allis, WI

Aggies’s Bakery and Cake Shop is loved by many in the metro-Milwaukee area.  Ordering is easy and the cakes are delicious. Choose from cheesecakes, tortes, cupcakes, and your favorite cake flavors. Aggie’s has won WeddingWire Brides Choice Awards and is featured on The Knot. You know you’ll be getting a great deal at Aggie’s.

4. Linda’s Bakery, West Salem, WI

Linda’s family-owned bakery located in West Salem has got western Wisconsin drooling over her cakes. She’s got 12 different cake flavors to win over everyone’s taste buds at your next event. Try their marble cake paired with their creamy chocolate butter creme frosting.

5. Rolling Pin Bake Shop, Fitchburg, WI

Rolling Pin Bake Shop in Fitchburg does more than just serve tasty food. They also provide top notch cakes within the Madison area. Whether you are looking for a customer birthday cake, a specialty cake, or a gorgeous wedding cake—Rolling Pin Bake Shop does it all. Order away, the possibilities are endless.

6. Café Coco, Washburn, WI

Washburn’s very own, Café Coco is more than just a café—ask about their cake selections! They have the perfect cake for your next event. From kid’s birthday parties to the most stunning wedding cakes, a cake from Coco is the way to go-go!

7. Craig’s Cake Shop, Verona, WI

Located on the outskirts of Madison is Craig’s cake Shop in Verona. They service cakes for all occasions. They have been voted Wisconsin Bride Magazine’s Best Cake for six years! Don’t just take our word for it, everyone in Madison loves Craig’s. Try their delicious carrot cake with your favorite frosting today!

8. Lakeland Bakery, Elkhorn, WI

Lakeland Bakery is taking cake orders! Name you’re your flavor, shape, size, and color. Leave the rest to the talented bakers at Lakeland Bakery. You’ll love all the of the different cake combinations. Try their fresh strawberry filled yellow cakes for the perfect summer get together!

9. Uncle Mike’s Bake Shoppe, Green Bay, WI

Uncle Mike’s award-winning Cake Shoppe is the tastiest in Green Bay. Voted Best of the Bay “Best Cakes” for 10 years in a row. There is no match for their quality cakes, beautiful, and tasty cakes. Try their made from scratch red velvet from scratch cake topped with their homemade cream cheese icing—you’ll thank us later for making Uncle Mike’s a member of your family!

10. Rich’s House of Cakes, Milwaukee, WI

This fourth-generation, family-owned business has been crafting custom cakes for over 50 years. Rich’s will make you cakes for baby showers, graduation parties, holidays, anniversaries, weddings, and more—all designed to your liking. Rich’s is known for making top-quality creations. 

Select a Wisconsin town to find the Best Things-To-Do and Places To Go around you
Find Bakeries and Pastry Shops Near You
Enter City / State or Zip code below
Select your town to find the Best Things-To-Do and Places To Go around you:

Adams County

Ashland County

Barron County

Bayfield County

Brown County

Buffalo County

Burnett County

Calumet County

Chippewa County

Clark County

Columbia County

Crawford County

Dane County

Dodge County

Door County

Douglas County

Dunn County

Eau Claire County

Florence County

Fond Du Lac County

Forest County

Grant County

Green County

Green Lake County

Iowa County

Iron County

Jackson County

Jefferson County

Juneau County

Kenosha County

Kewaunee County

La Crosse County

Lafayette County

Langlade County

Lincoln County

Manitowoc County

Marathon County

Marinette County

Marquette County

Menominee County

Milwaukee County

Monroe County

Oconto County

Oneida County

Outagamie County

Ozaukee County

Pepin County

Pierce County

Polk County

Portage County

Price County

Racine County

Richland County

Rock County

Rusk County

Saint Croix County

Sauk County

Sawyer County

Shawano County

Sheboygan County

Taylor County

Trempealeau County

Vernon County

Vilas County

Walworth County

Washburn County

Washington County

Waukesha County

Waupaca County

Waushara County

Winnebago County

Wood County